Doors off or doors on?

Every helicopter tour on Kauai falls on one side of a simple line. With the doors removed you sit beside an open frame with nothing between you and the cliffs, and with them closed you get a quiet, warm cabin behind large windows. Neither is better in general, so the right one depends on who is flying with you and what you want to come home with.

Four tours fly open, five keep the doors shut

Of the nine tours we compare, four fly with the doors removed. Ali'i Air Tours' private flight, from ~$425, is the flexible one, because only your own party of two or three is aboard and you choose doors off or doors on. Jack Harter's 60-minute MD500 flight, from ~$460, seats four passengers in a compact helicopter where each of them effectively has an outside seat. Air Kauai's doors-off adventure, from ~$386, is the shared version, with six passengers in the cabin and only some of them on the edge.

The fourth is the private doors-off flight with Mauna Loa Helicopters at ~$384, which we keep off the main list. Every seat in its small three-passenger helicopter is a window, but your party is weighed with its belongings at check-in, and anyone over the limit loses the flight without a refund. You also drive yourself from the check-in desk to the helipad.

The closed-cabin side is larger. Blue Hawaiian's Eco Adventure, from ~$449, flies an Eco-Star with six passenger seats and is the most reviewed helicopter tour on the island. Safari Helicopters keeps the doors on for both its Deluxe Waterfall Safari, from ~$336, and the version with a landing in Olokele Canyon, from ~$369. Two extras complete the picture. Blue Hawaiian's Princeville departure at ~$539 is the costliest per minute of all nine, a 45-minute flight with few reviews so far. Air Kauai's Ohana doors-on tour at ~$335 is too new on GetYourGuide to have a single review there.

What the open door changes

With the doors off there is no glass between you and the Na Pali cliffs. Photos come out free of reflections and window smudges, and you can look straight down into a valley instead of across at it. Ali'i reviewers keep returning to those glare-free pictures. You also feel the flight more. Wind pushes through the cabin and the rotor is louder in your headset, which some passengers love and others find tiring. Air Kauai warns that its doors-off ride is loud, and its reviewers agree.

It is colder than the tropics suggest, because you move fast at altitude with nothing to block the air. Reviewers mention the cold often. Ali'i asks guests to wear a fitted jacket. Air Kauai reviewers say staff hand out a jacket and goggles, and one Mauna Loa guest ended up buying a hoodie at check-in. Pack a layer even on a hot morning in Lihue; when to fly over Kauai covers the weather through the year.

The rules on loose items

Anything that slips out of your hand over an open door is gone for good, so the doors-off operators are strict.

  • Phones. Ali'i allows one device per person, on a strap, and provides lanyards. Jack Harter hands out wrist straps. Air Kauai lets you carry a phone and nothing else, so other cameras stay in the car;
  • Hats and bags. Not allowed, and selfie sticks stay on the ground too;
  • Hair. Tied back. Ali'i rules out claw clips, and Air Kauai asks for long hair in a braid or a bun;
  • Shoes. Closed-toe, or held on with a strap. Loose sandals are out;
  • Jewelry. Ali'i asks guests to leave large earrings behind.

Shooting through an open door takes a different grip and different settings; photographing Kauai from the air explains both.

What a closed cabin gives you

With the doors on, the cabin is quieter and warmer, and you can talk without shouting. Blue Hawaiian fits Bose noise-cancelling headsets with two-way microphones, so you can ask the pilot a question in the air. The windows are large, and many nervous flyers feel calmer behind glass than next to an open frame. Queasy stomachs and nervous flyers goes into that in more depth. Small children can come along too. Blue Hawaiian sets no minimum age and carries children under 2 free on a lap, while Safari's listings rule out only children under 2.

Glass brings two drawbacks. The first is reflections, since a white shirt or a bright phone screen shows up in the window and then in your photos. Blue Hawaiian advises dark clothing for that reason, and pressing the lens close to the glass without touching it helps. The second is the seat. In a six-seat cabin two passengers sit beside the pilot and the rest share the back, where the middle places see less. Seats are assigned for weight and balance, so you cannot book a window. One Blue Hawaiian reviewer paid extra to sit in front, and one family was split up in the back row. Seats, weight limits and the window explains how the seating works.

View from the cockpit over the instrument panel toward the Na Pali sea cliffs and deep blue ocean

The two kinds of flight side by side

TourFromDoorsCabinMinimum ageOn board
Ali'i Air Tours, private~$425Off or on, your choiceYour party of 2–3, every seat a window7, and ages 7–11 doors on onlyOne device per person, on a strap
Jack Harter, MD500~$460OffFour passengers, all outside seats10Phone on a wrist strap
Air Kauai, doors off~$386OffSix shared; edge seats for 16 and over10, with an adult until 18A phone only
Mauna Loa, private~$384OffYour party of 2–3, all window seats7, and ages 7–11 by a closed doorWeighed with your belongings
Blue Hawaiian, Eco Adventure~$449OnSix in an Eco-Star, seats assignedNone; under 2 free on a lapNo hats, bags or selfie sticks
Safari, both tours~$336–369OnSix, two in front and four behind2No hats, bags or selfie sticks

The rules come from the listings and can change, so read the ones shown in your booking step.

The one flight that lets you switch

The Ali'i flight is our pick partly because it takes the dilemma away. Only your party is aboard, two or three people with a minimum of two paying, so nobody sits in the middle and no stranger takes the door. A couple can fly with the doors off and get the open-air photos. A family with a child of 7 to 11 flies with the doors on, because the operator does not take that age group doors off, and everyone still gets a window. It costs ~$425 per person for an hour in the air from the commuter terminal at Lihue Airport, with check-in 45 minutes ahead for a safety video and briefing. Reviewers praise calm pilots and warm staff at the desk. The complaints are the wind and cold with the doors off, plus one flight held up by a seatbelt fault and a swap to another helicopter.

Your party alone, doors off or on

Ali'i Air Tours flies only your group of two or three, each at a window, for an hour from Lihue at ~$425 per person. Free cancellation until 24 hours before the flight.

Who should pick which

  • Photographers, and anyone who wants the open air. Doors off, ideally on the Ali'i flight or Jack Harter's MD500, where nobody sits in a middle seat;
  • A shared doors-off flight at a lower price. Air Kauai at ~$386, accepting a six-passenger cabin where the edge seats go to passengers 16 and over and the seating plan decides who gets one;
  • Families with young children. Doors on. Blue Hawaiian or Safari with toddlers, or the Ali'i flight with the doors closed from age 7. Kids, seniors and limited mobility has the age rules in full;
  • Nervous flyers and anyone who feels the cold. Doors on, ideally in Blue Hawaiian's quieter cabin, where a microphone lets you talk to the pilot;
  • Anyone set on standing in a canyon. The only landing comes with the doors on, on Safari's longer tour; see landing in Olokele Canyon;
  • Price first. The two cheapest flights both keep the doors on. What a Kauai helicopter tour costs puts all nine side by side.

Wind or glass

Before you pick a door

Can I choose doors off or doors on for the same Kauai tour?

Only on the Ali'i Air Tours private flight, from ~$425, where your party of two or three picks either. Children aged 7 to 11 fly with the doors on. Every other tour here is fixed one way or the other.

How cold is a doors-off helicopter flight?

Noticeably colder than the ground, because the wind comes straight in at speed. Doors-off reviewers often advise a jacket. Air Kauai reviewers say staff hand one out with goggles, and Ali'i asks for a fitted jacket.

How old do children have to be to fly doors off?

Jack Harter and Air Kauai take children from 10, and Air Kauai keeps the edge seats for passengers 16 and over. Ali'i takes children from 7 but only with the doors on until 12. Mauna Loa seats ages 7 to 11 next to a closed door.

Can I take a camera on a doors-off flight?

It depends on the operator. Air Kauai allows a phone and nothing else. Ali'i lets each guest bring a single strapped device, and Jack Harter supplies wrist straps. Bags and selfie sticks are not allowed anywhere.

Do windows spoil photos on a doors-on tour?

They can add reflections, especially from light clothing. Blue Hawaiian suggests dark clothing, and a lens held just off the window keeps most glare out.